Yet another example of somebody citing our Hickam's Dictum paper and apparently not reading it. Letter to editor not accepted, so published here:
Al-Timimi
et al1 report an interesting case of a man diagnosed with
peritoneal tuberculosis and chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML), claiming it to
be an instantiation of Hickam’s dictum (“a patient can have as many diseases as
he damn well pleases”). On reflection, it is self-evident that patients get
multiple diseases over the course of their lives. A published framework for
understanding multiple diagnoses requires consideration of timing of disease
onset, causation, and probability2. Having multiple diseases is only surprising if their
onset, as judged by symptoms, is simultaneous or nearly so. A diagnostician
must recognize that some findings of a work-up may represent incidentalomas3, that new diseases can superimpose upon pre-existing
disease, that so-called endpoint diagnoses4 must be sought, and complications and epiphenomena of
the primary diagnosis expected. Utilizing this framework, the principal
diagnosis explaining the chief complaint in this case was peritoneal
tuberculosis, and CML was either an incidentaloma (albeit a consequential one)
or an underlying cause of the tuberculosis (i.e., an endpoint diagnosis). Using
this framework has greater operational and explanatory value than Hickam’s
dictum for the diagnostician working in real time. He need only remember to be
wary of incidentalomas, red herrings and false positive results; and new onset
superimposed on pre-existing disease. The remainder of the time, all the
findings will be causally related and comprise a unifying diagnosis2. Only rarely – if ever – need he worry about the
simultaneous symptomatic onset of two unrelated diseases.
Scott K. Aberegg, MD, MPH
1. Al-Timimi Z, Chew G, Browne M, Mostert
C. Peritoneal Tuberculosis and Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia: A Case of Hickam's
Dictum. Med J Aust. Nov
2026;224(11)doi:10.5694/mja2.70326
2. Aberegg
SK, Poole BR, Locke BW. Hickam's Dictum: An Analysis of Multiple Diagnoses. J Gen Intern Med. Oct 28
2024;doi:10.1007/s11606-024-09120-y
3. Geelhoed
GW, Druy EM. Management of the adrenal "incidentaloma". Surgery. Nov 1982;92(5):866-74.
4. Kaplan HM, Birnbaum JF, Kulkarni PA.
Pursuit of "endpoint diagnoses" as a cognitive forcing strategy to
avoid premature diagnostic closure. Diagnosis
(Berlin, Germany). Nov 1 2022;9(4):421-429. doi:10.1515/dx-2022-0013